Three-car Garage: Affordable Fun with Mazda MX-5, MINI Electric, and Volkswagen Golf GTI

Road tester focused on real-world usability and ride quality. Owns a Porsche 718 Cayman (manual) and a Suzuki Jimny for winter duty.
In the world of motoring enthusiasts, the idea of a perfect three-car garage is a tantalizing dream. Imagine the thrill of owning a spirited sports car, a dynamic hatchback, and a chic electric vehicle—all for the price of a single electric SUV. Auto Express has made this dream accessible with a curated selection of three small, yet remarkably fun cars: the Mazda MX-5, MINI Electric, and Volkswagen Golf GTI. This trio not only promises driving excitement but also offers practicality and economy, all for under £35,000.
The Volkswagen Golf GTI has long been celebrated as the quintessential hot hatch, marrying performance with practicality. The Mk7 Golf GTI, available for just under £11,000, is a testament to this legacy. With its 227bhp turbocharged engine and Performance Pack enhancements, it delivers a punchy drive that thrills on open roads. Yet, it remains a reliable companion for daily commutes, thanks to its spacious interior and refined features. The tartan-upholstered sports seats and iconic golfball shifter add a touch of nostalgia, making every drive a blend of comfort and excitement. This model represents incredible value, especially when compared to the newer Mk8, which, despite being more expensive, does not quite match the allure of its predecessor. [Photo suggestion: Volkswagen Golf GTI]
The MINI Electric, priced at £12,700, offers a different kind of thrill—one that is silent yet exhilarating. While it lacks the roar of a petrol engine, the electric MINI compensates with its nimble handling and quick acceleration. True to the brand's reputation, it delivers a 'go-kart' driving experience that is both fun and eco-friendly. The 32.6kWh battery provides up to 145 miles of range, making it ideal for urban adventures. Its timeless design and premium interior ensure it remains a stylish choice, despite its compact size. The MINI Electric might not be the most spacious, but it stands out as a chic and pragmatic option for those looking to embrace electric mobility without compromising on fun. [Photo suggestion: MINI Electric - front]
Completing this trio is the Mazda MX-5, a car that enthusiasts often describe as the purest embodiment of driving joy. Available for £11,800, the MX-5 offers a back-to-basics sports car experience that is hard to match. Its lightweight construction and agile handling make it perfect for winding country roads, especially with the top down on a sunny day. The 158bhp naturally aspirated engine delivers a visceral thrill, and the manual gearbox provides a direct connection to the car that amplifies the driving experience. Beyond its exhilarating performance, the MX-5 is also economical, achieving impressive fuel efficiency due to its lightweight design. This makes it not only a pleasure to drive but also affordable to own. [Photo suggestion: Mazda MX-5]
These three cars represent more than just a collection of vehicles; they embody the diverse possibilities available to car enthusiasts on a budget. The combination of a hot hatch, an electric city car, and a classic roadster provides a well-rounded driving experience that caters to different moods and needs. From the practicality and heritage of the Golf GTI to the modern, environmentally-friendly MINI Electric, and the timeless thrill of the MX-5, each car brings something unique to the table. This selection underscores the potential for variety and excitement in a seemingly modest budget, challenging the notion that a fulfilling driving experience requires deep pockets.
As we look forward, the appeal of such a diverse garage only grows stronger. With the automotive industry shifting towards more sustainable and technologically advanced vehicles, the MINI Electric sets a benchmark for what future cars might offer in terms of performance and environmental impact. Meanwhile, the enduring charm of the Mazda MX-5 and the Volkswagen Golf GTI reminds us of the timeless joys of driving. For those considering expanding their automotive horizons, this trio offers a compelling mix of innovation, tradition, and sheer driving pleasure. It's a testament to the idea that with a bit of savvy shopping, the dream of a perfect three-car garage can become a reality.

About Marcus Reid
Road tester focused on real-world usability and ride quality. Owns a Porsche 718 Cayman (manual) and a Suzuki Jimny for winter duty.