Citroen e-C4 vs Volkswagen ID.3: Which Affordable EV is Best for the Family?

The Citroen e-C4, a crossover hatchback, has been around since 2020. Recently, it received a facelift and a price reduction of approximately £4,000, making it more appealing to budget-conscious buyers. With a 50kWh battery and a 134bhp electric motor, the e-C4 offers an official range of 219 miles. However, during tests, it averaged an efficiency of 3.6 miles per kWh. Despite its appeal, its drive modes are considered somewhat redundant, as the default mode suffices for most driving scenarios. The Citroen's design, a blend of practicality and style, includes a spacious interior and a boot with a clever design nod to its combustion-engine roots.

Volkswagen's ID.3 Essential is positioned as a cost-effective entry point into the brand's electric lineup. Priced at £30,860, it houses a 52kWh usable battery, offering an official range of 241 miles. In terms of efficiency, the ID.3 outperforms the e-C4, achieving 4.1 miles per kWh. The ID.3 is not just about the numbers; it incorporates features like adaptive cruise control and a more engaging driving experience thanks to its rear-wheel-drive configuration. Despite its higher price tag, the ID.3's additional features and improved efficiency may justify the cost for many buyers.

In terms of practicality, both the Citroen e-C4 and Volkswagen ID.3 offer ample space for families. The ID.3 provides slightly more room with better head and legroom, although both vehicles are comparable in width. Boot space is generous in both models, with the ID.3's longer and wider bay offset by a higher load floor due to its rear-mounted motor. When it comes to charging, Volkswagen offers a more rapid DC charging rate, significantly reducing wait times compared to the Citroen.

Ownership considerations reveal both models come with similar servicing costs and warranties. However, Volkswagen edges out Citroen in terms of roadside assistance, offering three years compared to Citroen's one. The ID.3 also maintains a higher residual value, indicating a slower depreciation rate, which might appeal to those considering long-term ownership. The Citroen, on the other hand, ranks higher in customer satisfaction surveys, suggesting a loyal customer base despite its few shortcomings.

Ultimately, choosing between the Citroen e-C4 and Volkswagen ID.3 depends on personal priorities. The ID.3's advanced features, efficient performance, and superior charging capabilities make it a compelling choice for those who prioritize technological advancements and range. Conversely, the Citroen e-C4, with its comfortable ride and competitive pricing, offers a strong case for families seeking practicality and affordability. As electric vehicles continue to evolve, these models represent significant strides towards making eco-friendly transportation accessible to the average family.